I weighed it so you don't have to.
If you've spent any time on r/ultralight or r/campinggear, you know the drill. Someone posts a gear list for a weekend trip and gets eviscerated for carrying a 3-pound tent. "Too heavy." "You can save 12 ounces by spending $400." "Why are you bringing a camp chair? Just sit on a rock."
Here's the thing: those people aren't wrong for themselves. They're just wrong for most of us.
I've been on both sides of this. Before I had kids, I was the guy obsessing over every gram, cutting toothbrush handles in half, and sleeping on a foam pad that felt like a yoga mat on concrete. Then I had a 7-year-old who wanted to bring a stuffed animal and a 9-year-old who insisted on "just one more" hoodie. And I realized that ultralight advice wasn't built for my life.
Let's talk about why.
The Ultralight Mindset Is Built for a Different Trip
Here's what ultralight is optimizing for: moving fast over long distances, often alone or with equally driven partners, usually for multiple days. Every ounce matters because you're carrying it 15 miles a day.
That's a legitimate goal. It's just not my goal.
My goal is getting two kids, one dog, and enough food for a weekend out of the car and into camp without anyone having a meltdown. I'm hiking 2–3 miles max. Comfort matters more than weight. Sanity matters more than speed.
The ultralight community is full of well-intentioned people with great advice. But that advice often assumes:
You're hiking solo or with one other adult
You're covering significant daily mileage
You're not dealing with children's whims, weather anxiety, or snack emergencies
You have the budget to replace heavy gear with expensive lightweight alternatives
You're willing to sacrifice convenience for weight savings
That's the advice that doesn't apply when a 9-year-old needs a real pillow to sleep and a 7-year-old thinks "minimalist" is a bad word.
What Ultralight Gets Right (For Everyone)
Let's be fair: the ultralight community has done incredible work advancing gear innovation. Some of the best lightweight products on the market exist because someone was obsessed with shaving ounces. We all benefit from that.
And some ultralight principles apply universally:
Pack what you actually use. This is the gold standard. Don't bring a backup for your backup. Don't pack "just in case" items that you've never needed. My first few family trips, I brought way too much "what if" gear. I've since cut that in half and haven't missed anything.
Weight matters, just not equally. The ultralight crowd focuses heavily on big three weight (tent, sleeping bag, pack) because those are where you can make the biggest impact. For family campers, that's also true—but the impact of 5 extra pounds on a 2-mile hike is much smaller than on a 15-mile hike.
Test your gear at home. Nobody wants to discover their new sleeping pad doesn't hold air at 10 PM in the dark. This is good advice for everyone. My backyard tests have saved me countless headaches.
What Ultralight Gets Wrong (For Families)
Here's where the advice starts to break down.
The "just sit on a rock" camp chair philosophy.
Reddit loves to tell people chairs are unnecessary. They're not wrong about the weight—camp chairs are bulky and heavy. But they're missing the point. On a family trip, a camp chair means:
A place to sit where a 7-year-old can actually reach the ground
A spot to cook without crouching awkwardly
A surface to dry wet socks and shoes on
A way to keep kids off the damp ground for 15 minutes of peace
I've tested multiple chairs specifically for wet grass mornings. The weight is worth it. And honestly, the ultralight backpacking chairs (like the Helinox Chair Zero) weigh less than a pound and pack small enough to justify. The problem is the philosophy that chairs are inherently frivolous.
The "kids can carry their own gear" assumption.
If you have a 7-year-old who can carry a 15-pound pack for a 3-mile hike, great. Mine can't. Or won't. Or will, but then complain for two hours about how heavy it is, which ruins the trip for everyone.
The reality: in a family trip, the adults carry the kids' gear. That's just how it works. So the adults need a system that's comfortable for them and reasonable for the total load. Ultralight advice assumes distribution of weight that doesn't match reality.
The "just use a quilt" sleeping advice.
I tested budget quilts against premium sleeping bags earlier this year, and here's my take: quilts are great for solo backpackers. For kids who wiggle, toss, and inevitably end up on the floor of the tent? Sleeping bags with hoods that zip all the way closed are non-negotiable. A 9-year-old under a quilt is a recipe for cold shoulders and a grumpy morning.
Ultralight wisdom says quilts save weight. Ultralight wisdom is also sleeping on a 7-inch pad with a quilt that requires technique to manage drafts. My 7-year-old doesn't have technique. My 7-year-old has a sleeping bag that wraps around him like a burrito.
The "cook efficiency" stove advice.
Ultralighters care about stove weight and fuel efficiency. They'll spend $100 on a tiny canister stove that saves 2 ounces. I care about whether my stove can boil water for ramen and hot chocolate for four people quickly enough that nobody gets hangry.
My stovetop boil time comparison showed that the cheapest canister stove still worked fine. But the ultralight priorities (minimum weight, maximum efficiency) don't align with family priorities (speed, reliability, ability to cook for a crowd).
What Family Campers Actually Need
Here's the gear advice I'd give to another parent, from my own testing and experience:
Carry a heavier tent that's easy to set up. The weight difference between a 4-pound tent and a 6-pound tent on a 2-mile hike is negligible. The difference between a "pitch in 10 minutes" tent and a "frustrating for 30 minutes" tent is the difference between a happy family and a stressed family.
Bring a real camp chair. Your back will thank you. Your kids will thank you. The "just sit on the ground" crowd doesn't have a 9-year-old who wants to eat breakfast without kneeling in dirt.
Use a sleeping bag, not a quilt, for kids. It's warmer and easier. The draft management that ultralighters pride themselves on is a losing battle with a restless 7-year-old.
Bring extras for the car. "Duffel bag backup camp gear"—extra jackets, extra snacks, a second stove—in a duffel in the trunk is the unsung hero of family camping. You won't carry it in your pack. But it's there if someone gets wet or cold or hangry. Ultralight purists would never. Parents should.
Don't buy ultralight gear for kids. They'll outgrow it before you get your money's worth. Buy reasonable gear, accept the weight, and don't overthink it.
The Reality Check
Here's what I've learned from my spreadsheet-driven, backyard-testing, gear-weighing approach:
Ultralight is a hobby. Family camping is a lifestyle.
That doesn't mean one is better. It means the advice that works for one doesn't necessarily work for the other. And that's okay.
The gear decisions I make for a family trip are different from the gear decisions I'd make for a solo overnight. I'm optimizing for different things: sanity, simplicity, comfort for kids, and the ability to actually enjoy the trip instead of spending the whole time managing gear.
The Bottom Line
Ultralighters are great. Many of them are friends of mine. But they're not living in my world, and their advice isn't always relevant.
If you're a parent trying to figure out what to pack, take the ultralight advice with a grain of salt. Ask yourself: "Does this advice apply to my trip with my kids?" Usually, the answer is no.
Good spec, mediocre experience? Ultralight advice is often a great spec for a different trip. Family camping needs something else.
— Tom
Letters
No letters yet — be the first to write.